Judge Dismisses Zea Antitrust Suit Against NAR With Prejudice
A Florida federal judge dismissed Jorge Zea's antitrust suit against the National Association of Realtors and affiliated groups with prejudice on November 16.
A federal judge in West Palm Beach, Florida, has ended the antitrust suit that broker Jorge Zea brought against the National Association of Realtors and a group of local associations and multiple listing services. The dismissal came on Monday, November 16, 2026, when U.S. District Judge William P. Dimitrouleas of the Southern District of Florida signed an order on the docket. The dismissal was with prejudice as to the remaining defendants, which means the plaintiff cannot refile his claims against them.
Zea, a licensed broker who represented himself in the case, filed a 122-page Complaint on August 15, 2025. According to the complaint, he operates SnapFlatFee, a brokerage that charges sellers a listing fee in exchange for limited services. His theory is that buyer's agents steer clients away from listings that offer reduced or no buyer-agent commission, and that the defendants caused this by declining to enforce their own rules. Those rules cover the display of listing broker contact information in IDX listings, a requirement that a buyer's agent have an executed written buyer-broker agreement with specified terms before touring a property, and a ban on MLS platforms letting users filter results by broker or by compensation. By allegedly refusing to enforce these rules, Zea claims that the defendants have competitively disadvantaged his discount-brokerage business.
The court found that the amended complaint did not plausibly allege an agreement or specific evidence of coordinated non-enforcement.
The case had narrowed well before this order. In March, the court dismissed Connecticut Association of Realtors, Smart MLS and West and Southeast Realtors of the Valley for lack of personal jurisdiction and forum non conveniens. In April, the court dismissed the original complaint against the remaining defendants without prejudice and gave Zea one more opportunity to amend. The April order also admonished Zea over his improper use of artificial intelligence and concomitant misrepresentations to the Court.
NAR responded through a spokesperson, who said the group was pleased with the decision. The statement added: "Steering is a prohibited practice under NAR policy and the Realtor Code of Ethics." The spokesperson also said that the Code of Ethics is enforced by state and local Realtor associations, and the enforcement of MLS rules are handled by each MLS.
Zea's complaint also targeted an NAR rule. According to Chief Magistrate Judge William Matthewman's report and recommendation, the plaintiff alleges that the 2025 MLS Antitrust Compliance Policy established by NAR in its MLS Handbook prevents MLSs from fixing commissions, and that this policy is not enforced.
What this means for in-house counsel
The court found no plausible agreement or specific evidence of coordinated non-enforcement. For associations and MLS members, counsel may want to keep case-level records showing how each complaint under the listing broker contact display rule, the buyer-broker agreement requirement, and the broker or compensation filter ban was reviewed and resolved. NAR said enforcement of the Code of Ethics sits with local associations and enforcement of MLS rules with each MLS, so counsel may want to confirm that those files exist, are dated, and reflect independent review.
Free weekly email
The Counsel House Brief
The week's most important legal news for general counsel and in-house teams, in one short email.
Counsel House corrects errors promptly. Spot one? Email daniel@counselhouse.org.