Counsel House
Antitrust & Regulatory

EU sends Greece's PPC a supplementary statement of objections in below-cost power pricing probe

The European Commission has added detail on how it tests whether PPC sold wholesale electricity below cost from 2013 to 2019. No infringement has been found.

two transmission towers during golden hour
Two transmission towers during golden hour. Photo by Quilia on Unsplash

The European Commission has sent Greek utility Public Power Corporation (PPC) a supplementary statement of objections in its antitrust investigation into alleged below-cost wholesale electricity sales. The Commission announced the step on Friday, according to Reuters, which is 13 November 2026. The probe covers 2013 to 2019.

The document adds detail to the Commission's methodology for assessing whether PPC supplied power in the Greek wholesale market below cost. A supplementary statement is not a finding of wrongdoing. It is procedural, and it gives the company further notice of the case and a chance to answer the analysis before the Commission decides whether to close the investigation or adopt a final decision.

What the Commission alleged in 2024

The supplementary document builds on the original statement of objections, issued on 7 February 2024. In that press release, the Commission said it had informed PPC of its preliminary view that it breached EU antitrust rules by selling electricity in the Greek wholesale market below cost, thereby excluding its main rivals.

The Commission's preliminary view was that PPC held a dominant position in the interconnected Greek wholesale electricity market, which then covered the mainland, the Ionian islands and a few Aegean islands. Between 2013 and 2019, PPC controlled all lignite and hydro capacity, as well as some natural gas and renewable generation plants.

The specific concern was pricing. The Commission said PPC may have abused its dominant position by supplying electricity from its lignite and gas plants at prices below their variable costs, meaning the costs that rise with the volume generated. The suspected effects were that independent power providers were marginalized and investment in more environmentally friendly energy was deterred. If the preliminary view is confirmed, the conduct would infringe Article 102 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, which prohibits abuse of a dominant position. The Commission stated at the time that sending a statement of objections does not prejudge the outcome of an investigation.

Timeline and PPC's position

The Commission opened its formal investigation in March 2021. PPC has said the case began with an inspection at its offices in February 2017. PPC said the Commission's preliminary view relates to the period from July 2013 to 31 December 2019. The investigation is case AT.40278.

PPC responded to the latest step in a market announcement dated 14 November. In it, PPC said the allegations concern a period before Greece redesigned its electricity market under the EU Target Model. It said it had cooperated throughout and would keep defending its rights. In its 2024 response, PPC also said the period was well before its transformation into a modern and sustainable energy company.

No fine has been set, and Court Cast reports that no infringement or consumer-loss figure has been established. Court Cast describes the central dispute as whether the refined cost methodology supports the preliminary view that the pricing was exclusionary conduct by a dominant company. That framing matters because, as Europe Says noted, selling at low prices does not automatically constitute an antitrust violation. The Commission has said that, once a statement of objections is issued, the parties can examine the investigation file, reply in writing and request an oral hearing.

What this means for in-house counsel

In our view, the supplementary statement suggests that a cost-based pricing case can be reopened on method, even after a first statement of objections. The cost benchmark used in a predatory pricing theory is a point of contest here. The Commission's 2024 release used variable costs. Counsel at dominant or near-dominant companies may want to know how their business defines costs, and whether pricing models, margin analyses and board papers use the same definitions. Inconsistent internal cost data can be hard to explain years later.

The case also shows how long a conduct inquiry can last. The conduct dates to 2013, the inspection to 2017, and the new objections to late 2026. Legal holds, document retention and privilege protocols for pricing and trading records may need to hold up over that span. Companies in concentrated markets, especially those with legacy generation or network assets and a large retail arm, may want to periodically test whether wholesale pricing could be read as exclusionary against smaller rivals.

Finally, watch how PPC argues the market-structure point. Its stated position is that the period predates the Target Model reforms. Whether that context affects the Commission's assessment is a question for the final decision, if there is one. Counsel advising regulated or formerly state-linked businesses should record the regulatory framework in force when pricing decisions were made, so that history is available if a regulator later reviews those decisions under Article 102.

Free weekly email

The Counsel House Brief

The week's most important legal news for general counsel and in-house teams, in one short email.

Counsel House corrects errors promptly. Spot one? Email daniel@counselhouse.org.

← All newsJoin Counsel House →