Counsel House
Antitrust & Regulatory

Judge Wise Declines to Dismiss DRAM Supply Antitrust Class Action Against Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron

A federal judge in San Jose found the complaint plausibly alleges a Sherman Act conspiracy. Defendants must answer by December 7.

macro shot photo of a computer RAM
Macro shot photo of a computer RAM. Photo by Liam Briese on Unsplash

U.S. District Judge Noël Wise signed an order on November 14, 2026 denying the defendants' motion to dismiss in Garciaguirre v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd., No. 5:26-cv-06345, a putative antitrust class action in the Northern District of California. The defendants are Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd., Samsung Semiconductor, Inc., SK Hynix Inc., SK Hynix America Inc. and Micron Technology, Inc. Their answers are due no later than December 7, 2026.

The ruling is a pleading-stage decision. It does not decide whether any conspiracy occurred.

What the plaintiffs allege

The named plaintiffs are seventeen consumers and small businesses from five states. They filed the complaint on June 25, 2026, alleging that since October 2022 the defendants have maintained a continuing agreement, combination or conspiracy in restraint of trade in the market for conventional DRAM, in violation of Section 1 of the Sherman Act. According to the court's summary, they allege the defendants simultaneously cut production, coordinated a pivot to high bandwidth memory (HBM), exited older DDR3 and DDR4 products, and otherwise decreased and locked up conventional DRAM supply.

The order identifies four alleged courses of parallel conduct: simultaneous production cuts from October 26, 2022 to April 7, 2023; a coordinated pivot to HBM beginning in March 2023; a coordinated exit from DDR4; and a refusal to re-expand conventional DRAM capacity. The plaintiffs allege that SK Hynix and Micron announced production cuts within three weeks of each other, on October 26, 2022 and November 16, 2022.

The plaintiffs allege that the three companies held over 91% of global DRAM revenue as of the third quarter of 2025, and that conventional DRAM prices rose 697% over 18 months. The court made no findings on those figures.

The court's reasoning

The defendants argued that each company made rational choices consistent with its own independent self-interest. They also contended the case reruns DRAM II, in which the Ninth Circuit affirmed dismissal of claims against the same defendants based on a 2016 to 2018 supply restriction. The court found that it is not a rerun.

Judge Wise gave the defendants part of their argument. The plaintiffs' core theory is that the companies diverted manufacturing and investment from conventional DRAM to HBM. The order says that shift, standing alone, might not be enough. The court found the plaintiffs alleged more. The judge pointed to newer alleged conduct including long-term HBM contracts, Samsung and SK Hynix allegedly refusing long-term deals with conventional DRAM buyers, Micron shutting down Crucial, and near-identical customer vetting questions all three adopted in January 2026. The judge also declined to ignore the 1998 to 2002 DRAM cartel, in which Samsung and Hynix paid fines and Micron received immunity.

The order also granted the defendants' unopposed administrative motion to continue early case deadlines. Because the court reset the argument date by about three weeks, it moved the initial case deadlines to match. A case management conference is set for January 12, 2027.

Who is involved

Judge Wise is the district judge who issued the order. The docket also lists Magistrate Judge Virginia K. DeMarchi on the case. Yavar Bathaee and Edward M. Grauman of Bathaee Dunne LLP represent the plaintiffs.

What this means for in-house counsel

Discovery is now the practical concern. Once answers are filed, the plaintiffs can seek internal communications and planning documents on capacity, production cuts, HBM allocation and customer contracting. Legal departments at the three defendants should confirm that litigation holds reach engineering, supply planning, sales and executive staff. They should also review how capacity decisions and customer communications from late 2022 onward were documented.

The order shows which facts moved the court past the line between parallel conduct and plausible agreement. A business shift toward a more profitable product was not enough by itself. Allegations of similar conduct by competitors, alongside refusals to expand supply and near-identical vetting questions put to customers, carried more weight. In-house lawyers at any concentrated-market company should ask whether similar patterns exist in their own pricing, capacity or customer-screening practices. They should also ask whether the independent business rationale is recorded at the time decisions are made.

Buyers of DRAM and DRAM-containing products should note the ruling too. It does not establish liability, and the class has not been certified. Procurement and legal teams may still want to preserve purchasing records, long-term agreement negotiations and supplier communications. Companies that have signed or declined long-term supply agreements should keep a clear record of the commercial reasons behind each decision.

Free weekly email

The Counsel House Brief

The week's most important legal news for general counsel and in-house teams, in one short email.

Counsel House corrects errors promptly. Spot one? Email daniel@counselhouse.org.

← All newsJoin Counsel House →