DOJ closes NextEra-Dominion antitrust probe after merging parties commit to limits on New England plant shutdowns
The Antitrust Division ended its review of the $66.8 billion deal after the companies told FERC they would accept market monitor oversight of plant deactivations in ISO-NE.
The Justice Department's Antitrust Division has closed its investigation into NextEra Energy Inc.'s planned acquisition of Dominion Energy Inc. The Department announced the decision on November 19, 2026, after the companies committed in a Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) filing to give up their unilateral right to deactivate generating units in New England.
NextEra and Dominion announced on May 18 an agreement to combine in a $66.8 billion transaction. The Department said both companies generate electricity and compete in wholesale electricity and capacity auctions run by regional transmission organizations (RTOs) and independent system operators (ISOs). Their overlapping generation portfolios sit in two of those grid regions: PJM Interconnection LLC, which covers parts of the Midwest and Mid-Atlantic, and ISO New England Inc. (ISO-NE).
The market monitor's concern
The parties have applied to FERC for approval of the transaction, which the Department said federal law requires. During that review, the Internal Market Monitor of ISO-NE filed comments on the deal's potential effect on the capacity market. Capacity markets pay generators to keep plants available to run during peak demand, separate from what they earn selling electricity.
According to the Department, the Internal Market Monitor said the merged company might have the incentive and ability to deactivate a plant that is still economically viable, in order to use its combined portfolio to raise capacity payments in New England. The monitor proposed a remedy. For five years, starting with the next ISO-NE capacity auction in May 2028, the monitor could investigate any plant the merged firm proposes to deactivate. If the monitor found the plant still had economic value, NextEra would be prohibited from deactivating it.
The Division's review and the commitment
The Division said its own investigation included document review, interviews of industry participants and economic modeling. It said it remained concerned about the effect on ISO-NE's capacity market. After the Division told the parties of those concerns, they told FERC in a docket filing that they would "commit, without qualification, to comply" with the monitor's proposal, whether or not FERC imposes it as a condition of approval.
The Department said that commitment, which removes the parties' unilateral right to deactivate units in New England, will protect consumers in the region from potentially hundreds of millions of dollars in increased electricity costs. That figure is the Department's characterization. The Division said that in light of its review and the commitment to FERC, it decided the investigation could be closed.
In its statement, the Division said it is focused on ensuring electricity customers benefit from competition among generators. It said wholesale electricity and capacity markets must be competitive and not open to exploitation that could leave businesses and consumers facing higher bills as demand on grids grows.
The statement does not describe any remedy tied to the parties' overlapping assets in PJM. FERC's review of the application is described as ongoing.
What this means for in-house counsel
For counsel on energy deals with overlapping generation in an RTO or ISO, the sequence here is instructive. Inference from these facts: if your deal has similar overlaps, read the relevant market monitor's filings early and consider whether a behavioral commitment filed in the FERC docket can address them before the Division's review concludes.
If you advise a generator with ISO-NE assets, check any contract terms or internal plans that depend on a unilateral right to retire or deactivate units. In this deal the parties accepted a five-year monitor review starting with the May 2028 capacity auction, and they said they would comply even if FERC does not impose it.
Free weekly email
The Counsel House Brief
The week's most important legal news for general counsel and in-house teams, in one short email.
Counsel House corrects errors promptly. Spot one? Email daniel@counselhouse.org.