Counsel House
Privacy & Compliance

Delaware Bankruptcy Judge Orders Privacy Ombudsman to Review Character.AI's Sale of User Chats

Judge Brendan Shannon's Nov. 17 order puts a privacy review in front of a $10 million bid for the Character.AI app, its models and users' chat data.

padlock on laptop with light trails
Padlock on laptop with light trails. Photo by FlyD on Unsplash

A federal bankruptcy judge in Delaware on Nov. 17 ordered the appointment of a consumer privacy ombudsman to review the planned sale of Character.AI's consumer platform, which includes user accounts and chat content, ahead of a Dec. 1 auction. Judge Brendan L. Shannon of the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware signed the order in the Chapter 11 case of Character Technologies Inc. (No. 26-11603) at the request of U.S. Trustee Andrew R. Vara, with the debtor's consent.

According to Law360, Shannon adopted the narrower form of order proposed by the company rather than a broader version submitted by a group of state attorneys general. PPC Land reported that the order leaves the ombudsman to decide which sensitive information, beyond basic identifiers, counts as personally identifiable information under the Bankruptcy Code, and that the order does not specifically list chats or advertising profiles. The order also states that it is not an admission that the company failed to follow its privacy policies or that the sale complies with them.

On Nov. 18, the U.S. Trustee's office filed a notice appointing Lucy L. Thomson, founder of Livingston PLLC, as ombudsman, PPC Land reported. Thomson, a former Justice Department trial attorney, has been appointed consumer privacy ombudsman in 40 prior bankruptcy cases since 2008 and will bill $650 an hour subject to court approval. Her report is to be filed under seal first and is due no later than seven days before the sale hearing, which is set for Dec. 3 and 4.

What is for sale

Character Technologies filed for Chapter 11 on Oct. 12, 2026, according to Bankruptcy Observer. On Nov. 14, the company designated Smirks and Pangs Acquisition LLC as a stalking horse bidder offering $10 million in cash plus assumed liabilities for the consumer platform, including the website and mobile apps, its AI models and weights, end-user account information, user-created characters and chat content. A separate $20 million stalking horse bid from Disney Worldwide Services Inc. covers a license to certain intellectual property and technology and excludes chat logs.

Bloomberg Law reported that the company's chat logs come from more than 20 million users, with more than 2 million accounts belonging to minors. The Pennsylvania Attorney General's office said the platform has 12 million current users who spend an average of 120 minutes a day on it.

States press for protections

On Oct. 23, 32 states objected to the proposed bidding procedures, and on Oct. 29, 39 states and the District of Columbia supported the U.S. Trustee's call for an ombudsman, according to PPC Land. According to the Pennsylvania and Alaska attorneys general, the states began investigating Character.AI after a 2024 wrongful death lawsuit that alleged the company's chatbots fostered an exploitative relationship with a child and reinforced his suicidal thoughts.

Pennsylvania Attorney General Dave Sunday said in a Nov. 20 release that his office and other states will object to any sale or plan that lacks strong protections for personal data. "Children who are using these chatbots should not have their information sold to the highest bidder or otherwise misused," Sunday said. Alaska Acting Attorney General Cori Mills said the company's voluntary limits on minors' access to certain features are incomplete and could be reversed by a future buyer. "Children and families should not have to worry that their private conversations can be sold to the highest bidder," Mills said.

Under Section 363(b)(1) of the Bankruptcy Code, if a debtor's privacy policy in effect when the case was filed bars transferring personally identifiable information to unaffiliated parties, the debtor may sell that information only if the sale is consistent with the policy, or if, after a consumer privacy ombudsman is appointed, the court approves it, giving due consideration to the facts and finding no showing that the sale would violate applicable nonbankruptcy law.

What this means for in-house counsel

The key question is what the privacy policy in effect when the case was filed said about transfers to outside parties. Because the ombudsman will decide which sensitive data counts as personally identifiable information, chat content could be swept in. Companies that hold conversational or AI-generated user data should review whether their privacy policies address transfers in a bankruptcy, merger or asset sale, and whether those terms cover chat logs and derived models, not just contact details.

Buyers bidding on distressed technology assets should check the seller's privacy policy early: if it restricts transfers, the court must appoint a consumer privacy ombudsman under Section 332 of the Bankruptcy Code before approving a sale of personal data, and state attorneys general may object, as they did here, when minors' data is involved. Buyers should build time for a sealed ombudsman report and a Section 363(b)(1) hearing into the deal calendar, with deal terms that can absorb court-imposed limits on use of the data.

Free weekly email

The Counsel House Brief

The week's most important legal news for general counsel and in-house teams, in one short email.

Counsel House corrects errors promptly. Spot one? Email daniel@counselhouse.org.

← All newsJoin Counsel House →