California privacy agency fines Hertz $1.55 million over alleged failure to honor opt-out signals, imposes three years of testing
Under a stipulated order, Hertz must pay $1.55 million and test opt-out compliance quarterly for three years, without admitting liability under the CCPA.
The California Privacy Protection Agency, which now styles itself CalPrivacy, announced on November 17 that its Board has ordered The Hertz Corporation to pay a $1.55 million administrative fine and overhaul how it handles consumer opt-outs under the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA). The Board adopted the stipulated final order on November 6, in Case No. ENF25-001-V-HE. The order covers the Hertz, Dollar and Thrifty brands.
The agency's Enforcement Division alleged that Hertz failed to process opt-out preference signals, failed to tell consumers how it processed them, and added unnecessary friction to the opt-out process. Hertz agreed to the fine and said it would change its business practices.
What the order says
The order's factual findings cover July 1, 2023 to August 25, 2026. They state that Hertz placed tracking technologies from Meta, Google, Pinterest, LinkedIn, Microsoft, TikTok, The Trade Desk, LiveRamp, Adobe, Amazon, Sojern, Criteo, Wunderkind and others on its digital properties. According to the findings, those tools made identifiers and rental details available to ad tech companies for cross-context behavioral advertising.
The findings state that for a portion of the period Hertz did not configure its sites to detect and honor signals such as Global Privacy Control (GPC). They also state that Hertz continued to sell or share the data of consumers who sent those signals, and that its privacy policy did not explain how it handled such signals.
A third finding concerns Dollar.com and Thrifty.com. Their "Manage Cookies" windows showed advertising cookies as switched off. If a user closed the window without clicking "Save Changes," the settings reverted to defaults that allowed advertising cookies. The order says this additional, non-obvious step may have been confusing and would violate the CCPA regulations on consumer choice design.
Hertz admitted only paragraphs 1 to 5 and 24 to 29 of the order. Those cover the parties, jurisdiction and background facts, including that it knew consumers had the right to opt out of sale or sharing. It neither admitted nor denied the remaining findings, and the order states that it does not admit liability for any CCPA violation. The order also records that Hertz cooperated with the investigation and took corrective action while it was under way.
Operational requirements
The non-monetary terms run for three years from the effective date. Hertz must:
- scan its properties at least quarterly to keep a current inventory of tracking technologies that sell or share personal information;
- check for a consumer's GPC signal before loading those technologies;
- test opt-out configurations in staging and production, across browsers, mobile platforms, tag management containers and both known and unknown users, at least quarterly and whenever a new tracker is added;
- run an internal review before onboarding any third party that receives personal information;
- independently assess its consent management platform or service providers at least twice a year, rather than rely on their representations; and
- report publicly how many opt-out requests arrived through preference signals.
Hertz has 60 days from the decision's effective date to pay and 180 days to complete system changes. The Agency releases its CCPA claims over the conduct in the findings once Hertz complies. Non-compliance would be enforced in California Superior Court. Christopher M. Murphy, Hertz's senior vice president and deputy general counsel, signed for the company. Winston Taylor LLP attorney Alessandra Swanson signed as to form. Enforcement Division attorneys Lisa B. Kim and Gary Lee handled the case.
Lara Kehoe Hoffman, the agency's Acting Deputy Director of Enforcement, said in the announcement: "Companies cannot ignore those choices or shift responsibility to others."
Related actions
The Board announced a separate decision against outdoor clothing retailer CC Filson Co. It must pay $217,987 and stop device-based sales and sharing of Californians' personal information to ad tech companies within 30 days, until it can certify compliance. The agency said the Filson fine reflected confidential financial information showing the company could not pay a multi-million dollar penalty. Last week the agency also announced a $2.975 million fine against Federal Express. The agency noted that the California Opt Me Out Act, which requires browsers operating in California to offer opt-out preference signals, takes effect in January 2027.
What this means for in-house counsel
The order treats the technical behavior of a website as a legal compliance question. A banner that looks correct but does not suppress trackers, or a tag manager that fires before the GPC check, is the kind of failure the order describes. Legal teams should ask privacy engineering for evidence that opt-out signals suppress sale and sharing before tags load, in both staging and production. They should also ask how often that is tested. Counsel may want to consider the quarterly testing across browsers and containers that the order requires of Hertz as a reference point.
The order also bars Hertz from relying solely on a vendor's statements about consent management. Counsel who rely on a consent platform's assurances should check contracts for audit rights and decide who independently verifies the platform's behavior. Third-party onboarding deserves attention too, because the order requires Hertz to run an internal review process to confirm that contracts and opt-out configurations are completed before it onboards a third party.
Finally, review the design of cookie preference windows. The order's findings on Dollar.com and Thrifty.com show that default toggle states and unsaved changes can be treated as a choice-architecture problem. Public opt-out metrics, including the count of preference-signal requests, are another disclosure item to prepare for. The agency's stated expectation is that businesses have been on notice for years, so a record of testing and remediation before any inquiry may matter.
Free weekly email
The Counsel House Brief
The week's most important legal news for general counsel and in-house teams, in one short email.
Counsel House corrects errors promptly. Spot one? Email daniel@counselhouse.org.