Counsel House
Outside Counsel

Relation's cyber practice leader says law firms may see a 'mini-hard market' first

Courtney Maugé of Relation Insurance Services says rising cyber claims could tighten terms for law firms before other sectors.

red padlock on black computer keyboard
Red padlock on black computer keyboard. Photo by FlyD on Unsplash

Cyber insurers could begin raising rates by industry class, and law firms could be among the first groups to see the change. That is the view of Courtney Maugé, cyber practice leader at Relation Insurance Services, who spoke to The Insurer TV at the Zywave Cyber Risk Conference in New York in late October. The interview was published on November 20, 2026.

Maugé said that, even with abundant capacity and continued competition, rising claims activity is pressuring the market. Her words on law firms were direct: “I think law firms are going to first see their little mini-hard market.” She said the tightening could later spread to other commercial sectors. She also said professional services firms, and businesses holding large amounts of sensitive information or trade secrets, remain a particular concern for cyber underwriters, with data exfiltration continuing to drive claims.

Maugé also pointed to overlap between cyber and other lines. In her example, a ransomware attack could lead to property damage, business interruption or even securities litigation. That raises a practical question about which policy should respond and which underwriter is best placed to price the exposure. She added that the small and middle market remains underpenetrated, and that many smaller businesses still have trouble understanding the value of coverage after the sharp premium increases of the previous hard market.

Other data also points to rising claims activity. Coalition's July 31, 2026 blog post by Daniel Woods reported that the frequency of privacy rights claims doubled in the first half of 2026 compared with 2025. The post also said a serial pro se litigant, Vivek Shah, “outpaced all law firms combined” in demand-letter volume.

What this means for in-house counsel

If your company buys cyber cover for its own operations, ask your broker now how renewal pricing will be built for your industry class, and whether your ransomware wording would respond to property damage, business interruption or securities claims. Maugé described scenarios in which a ransomware attack could trigger such losses. Map those overlaps across cyber, property, D&O and professional liability before your next renewal, so that you know which policy pays first.

If you rely on outside law firms, the same underwriting pressure may reach them. Write into engagement terms a requirement that the firm carry cyber cover with stated limits, provide certificates on renewal, and give notice of a security incident within a set number of hours. Because Maugé said data exfiltration drives claims, counsel may also want to ask outside counsel about encryption at rest and how long client files are retained.

Free weekly email

The Counsel House Brief

The week's most important legal news for general counsel and in-house teams, in one short email.

Counsel House corrects errors promptly. Spot one? Email daniel@counselhouse.org.

← All newsJoin Counsel House →