Counsel House
AI & Legal Tech

Ontario appeal court keeps Canadian publishers' AI copyright suit against OpenAI in Canada

The Court of Appeal for Ontario rejected OpenAI's bid to move the news organizations' training-data case to the United States.

The image shows the chatgpt app on a phone
The image shows the chatgpt app on a phone. Photo by Zulfugar Karimov on Unsplash

The Court of Appeal for Ontario on Nov. 13, 2026 dismissed OpenAI's appeal of a ruling that Ontario courts can hear a copyright lawsuit brought by five Canadian news organizations. The decision means the case, which accuses OpenAI of using Canadian journalism to train the models behind ChatGPT, will proceed in Ontario rather than in the United States, where OpenAI argued it belonged.

The plaintiffs are Toronto Star Newspapers Limited and Metroland Media Group (Torstar), Postmedia Network, The Globe and Mail, The Canadian Press and the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation. They sued in 2024. It is described as the first Canadian case on using copyrighted material to train generative AI.

What the appeal court decided

The Court of Appeal upheld the November 2025 ruling of Justice Jessica Kimmel of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, Commercial List. It rejected OpenAI's position that Ontario courts could not hear claims against its Delaware-based companies, leaving the case in Ontario.

The court did not rule on whether OpenAI infringed anything. The publishers allege infringement under the Copyright Act, circumvention of technological protection measures, breach of the Terms of Use on their websites, and unjust enrichment, all tied to scraping their content, training models on it and selling the resulting products. None of those allegations has been tested at trial.

What the lower court found

Justice Kimmel's decision, Toronto Star Newspapers Limited v. OpenAI Inc., 2025 ONSC 6217, dated Nov. 7, 2025, worked through each of the 10 OpenAI entities named as defendants. She held that the court had subject matter jurisdiction over all of the claims, writing that such jurisdiction "either exists, or it does not." She treated OpenAI's argument that the Copyright Act is a complete code as a merits question, and made no ruling on arbitration clauses that no party relied on.

She then found connecting factors to Ontario for six defendants. OpenAI, Inc., OpenAI OpCo, LLC and OpenAI, LLC were found to have carried on business in Ontario and to have allegedly committed wrongful acts there, and two of them were treated as parties to the publishers' Ontario-based Terms of Use. OpenAI Holdings, LLC, OAI Corporation and OpenAI Global, LLC stayed in the case on the unjust enrichment claim as parent companies said to profit from the subsidiaries' conduct. Service on four other entities, including OpenAI GP, LLC and the OpenAI Startup Fund vehicles, was set aside.

Two limits in her reasoning matter for the next phase. She held that creating a work in Ontario does not by itself bring a copyright claim within the province, because the alleged breach must occur there. She also observed that most of the alleged conduct took place outside Canada, which could narrow the claims later even though it did not defeat jurisdiction. She also found OpenAI had not shown the United States was a clearly more appropriate forum.

Several of the same publishers filed a separate suit against Anthropic earlier this year, and the federal government in Ottawa has not said whether it will amend the Copyright Act to address AI training.

What this means for in-house counsel

For AI developers and companies that license or deploy their models, the ruling confirms that a foreign defendant cannot count on pulling a training-data dispute back to its home courts. Ontario judges looked at where the company did business, whose website terms it allegedly accepted when scraping, and which affiliates collected the revenue. Legal teams should map which group entities operate, contract and earn money in each country where content was collected, since the court sorted defendants along exactly those lines.

Publishers and other content owners should note how much weight the court gave to ordinary website Terms of Use. A contract claim based on site terms, governed by local law, gave the plaintiffs a hook that did not depend on where servers or training runs were located. Reviewing those terms, including choice of law, forum and limits on automated collection, is worthwhile.

With the jurisdiction ruling upheld, the case moves toward the merits, including the territorial reach of the Copyright Act, which Justice Kimmel left open. Companies relying on AI vendor indemnities for third-party IP claims should read them with that question in mind.

Free weekly email

The Counsel House Brief

The week's most important legal news for general counsel and in-house teams, in one short email.

Counsel House corrects errors promptly. Spot one? Email daniel@counselhouse.org.

← All newsJoin Counsel House →